COVID-19 Corona Virus
South African Resource Portal
COVID-19 Corona Virus
South African Resource Portal
COVID-19 Corona Virus
South African Resource Portal
 
Submit an article to Indago - a peer reviewed journal
Submit an article to Indago - a peer reviewed journal
Submit an article to Indago - a peer reviewed journal

Recently the National Museum held an exhibition about body art and its relationship to identity.  As part of this display visitors were introduced to ‘Ötzi’, the oldest known example of a tattooed body.  Ötzi was named after the region in the Ötzal Alps near the Similaun mountain refuge in north-west Italy, where he was discovered in 1991 by hikers in a thawing glacier pool.  Currently he is kept preserved in a perfectly controlled environment in the South Tyrol Museum of Archaeology, in Bolzano, Italy, where he provides an invaluable view into Neolithic man’s life and environment.

Ötzi’s mummified remains, along with an assortment of possessions such as his clothing, a bow and arrows, a dagger and sheath, and an axe were remarkably well preserved by the glacier that enshrined him for about 5 300 years. Careful examination of his body and effects has provided a wealth of information about the Copper Age and stimulated a profusion of discussions about the man, his life and his demise.

Some of the most popular dialogues revolve around Ötzi’s 61 tattoos that were created by rubbing soot into incisions. They are simple groupings of one to seven lines of varying lengths and thicknesses, placed parallel to the longitudinal axis of his body. There are also two crosses present on his right knee and ankle. The popularity of these discussions could be attributed to how this find has challenged or contradicted previously believed theories on the origins and practice of tattooing, medicine and acupuncture therapy.

Originally investigators concurred that these tattoos were most likely therapeutic in nature rather than communicative or aesthetic. Their location above joints commonly linked to musculoskeletal ailments and key acupuncture lines makes it plausible that they served either as treatment for, or markers of, chronic pain. Clinical examinations of Ötzi’s body have shown clear indications of osteoarthritis and musculoskeletal injury and strain. Some visible injuries or degeneration have correlating tattoos while others do not. Similarly some tattoos are located over clearly afflicted areas, while some are present where no ailment is evident. These theories easily become circular in nature, as the presence of these two aspects are often used to support theories of one or another, even in instances where there is no physical evidence. Much of this is based on the deduction that Ötzi suffered from chronic pain due to mechanical back injury, lower lumbar compression, sciatic nerve (which runs from the lower back to the back of the foot) referred pain and joint strain.

In 2015 the application of new imaging techniques, observing beyond the visible spectrum, lead to the unexpected discovery of a previously unseen tattoo on the lower right side of Ötzi’s chest.  This discovery has brought the overall acceptance of the ‘medicinal’ theory into question since the tattoo is not, like the others, located on or near a joint.

Ötzi is one of many mummified remains with tattoos. Other examples such as those discovered in the Sciite tombs of Pazyryk in the Ural Mountains of Siberia (6th century BCE), differ in that their markings are far more elaborate or pictorial. One of these, known as  the ‘Prince of the Sciites’ or the ‘Sciites Warrior’, has decorative tattoos on his arms, chest, back and right leg, as well as point-like tattoos along his spine that do not indicate any ornamental function. Their application and placement are assumed to have a therapeutic or ritualistic function.

Similarly the recently discovered remains of a 1000 year old Peruvian mummy revealed two distinct types of tattoos. Simplified geometric tattoos located on the back of her neck were made using a different substance than the rest of her tattoos. The pigment used included plant material which seems to support the idea that they held some curative or ritualistic significance.

Without disputing the acceptability of the ‘medicinal’ argument it is equally possible that Ötzi’s tattoos served a decorative purpose.  Simplicity does not necessarily denote meaninglessness, and culturally not all tattoos are communicative. The time that it takes to execute a tattoo, its permanence, and painfulness imply a contemplation and presence of mind that cannot be thoughtless.  In some instances tattoos play an integral role in the expression of ego, the development of personal identity, and the practice of spirituality and ritual.

The artefacts found with Ötzi show an understanding of design without being overly decorative. Sensitivity to both form and function are evident. Undoubtedly, time was spent creating an object that would work well while also being visually pleasing. This is especially clear when viewing his knife sheath. Time, effort and thought was spent on creating an appealing design that, if merely utilitarian, could have been achieved in a much simpler and faster manner. This same rationale could be applied to the visual character of his tattoos.

It can be argued that Ötzi’s tattoos are too elaborate to be mere markers that chart areas of chronic pain. Creating a composition of painful marks where one small dot would suffice, seems excessive.  While non-physical implications, intentions or motives are extensive and interesting to debate, they remain unquantifiable.

References

Cooper-White,M. 2015. Strange new tattoo discovered on ‘Ötzi the Iceman’ mummy. Huffington Post. Accessed: http://huffingtonpost.com/2015/01/26/otzi-iceman-new-tattoo_n_6546884.html.  (05.07.2016)

Kean, W. et al. 2013. The musculoskeletal abnormalities of the Similaun Iceman (“ÖTZI”): clues to chronic pain and possible treatments.  Inflammopharmacology 21(1): 11-20.

Capasso, L. 1993. A preliminary report on the tattoos of the Val Senales mummy (Tyrol, Neolithic).  Journal of Paleopathology  5(3): 173-182.

Samadelli, M. et al. 2015. Complete mapping of the tattoos of the 5 300-year-old Tyrolean Iceman.  Journal of Cultural Herritage 16:753-758.

Pabst, M.A. et al. 2009. The tattoos of Tyrolean Iceman: a light microscopical, ultrastructural and elemental analytic study.  Journal of Archeological Science 36(10): 2335-2341.

Schildkrout, E. 2004. Inscribing the Body.  Annual Review of Anthropology 33: 319-344.

mapping-of-tattoos

Mapping Ötzi’s tattoos.  (Photo:  EURAC/M.Samadelli/M.Melis)

multispectral-imaging

Additional tattoo found by multispectral imaging.  (Photo: EURAC/M.Samadelli/M.Melis)

oetzi_dolch

Knife and sheath found with the mummified remains of Ötzi.  (Photo: EURAC/M.Samadelli/M.Melis)

Altai-Princess

Mummified remains of a female known as the ‘Altai Princess’ or ‘Ukok Princess’ from the Sciite tombs of Pazyryk, Siberia, showing elaborate pictorial tattoos.  (Photo: Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences)

information_items_411

Drawing by Elena Shumakova, Institute of Archeology and Ethnography, Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Science, documenting the tattoos of the male mummy from the Sciite tombs of Pazyryk, Siberia, known as the ‘Prince of the Sciites’ or the ‘Sciite warrior’.  Note the stark  difference between the grouping of dots along his spine and the rest of his tattoos.  (Photo: Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences)

Comments are closed.